Save the shard! Vote for the Zero Tolerance Bill!

Name says it all
Locked

Is this shard ready for zero tolerance?

Poll ended at Sat May 09, 2009 4:40 pm

Yes! Let's protect our shard and our staff!
21
54%
No, I don't like consequences!
18
46%
 
Total votes: 39

Violette
Novice Scribe
Posts: 6
Joined: Tue Apr 07, 2009 6:08 am

Re: Save the shard! Vote for the Zero Tolerance Bill!

Post by Violette »

Zero tolerance is.. please pardon me here.. BS.. its a way to weed out people the people in charge don't like, Afk macros are not against the rules, which are listed in the codex as this:

4. Programs, macroing, exploiting:
a. Any kind of client or program is allowed to connect to this server, as long as it does not harm the integrity or performance of the server in any way.
b. Macroing allowed, even while you are away from keyboard, except for activities listed in rule 4.c. below.
c. When performing the following activities, you must not be away from keyboard: killing spawn (regular or champions), leveling weapons, fishing, gathering ore/wood/leather/wool/plants. This may not be a final list - the idea is that you should not perform anything that brings a good amount of wealth while AFK.
d. Exploiting the game in any way is prohibited and will be punished by a long term or permanent ban.

Enforcing a rule like this would cause MORE not less problems for the GMs who already leave problems in que for hours at a time.. The solution I'd suggest is enforce the rules already in place and get more active staff, the shard is over a hundred players on a week night, there needs to be about 5 staffers on, 1 per 20 or so people. But issuing a poll that's not really a poll but a set of questions deliberately designed to lead to a set conclusion, rather than a true measure of what the population thinks is an ultimately rather insulting and leads to you getting posts where people are rather polity calling ya an out of touch person of limited intellect. May I humbly suggest a: yes this is a good idea and b: no this isn't a good idea rather than coloring the options with your own bias, you'll get a better actual idea of what people think.. assuming that's actually what your interested in.
A Black Death
Elder Scribe
Posts: 108
Joined: Tue Feb 03, 2009 12:01 pm
Location: MO, usa
Contact:

Re: Save the shard! Vote for the Zero Tolerance Bill!

Post by A Black Death »

well im CERTAINLY not at a loss for words, ill keep it simple i have only 2 sentances
@alaware LOLOLOLOLOLOLOLOL you make me laugh crazy man :)

@llexa LOLOLOLOLOLOLOLOLOL can you truley be So blind to the ways of mankind , read the bible please please LOLOLOL forgive forgive forgive forgive all shal be forgiven and blessed is thy soul!
A Black Death, fav songs by candle box rain and he calls home
if ya ever need help and your not a tool just pm me ill see what i can do for ya
14+years UO vet , reached vet status on ex in 3 months so got a q ill try to answer it too
A Black Death
Elder Scribe
Posts: 108
Joined: Tue Feb 03, 2009 12:01 pm
Location: MO, usa
Contact:

Re: Save the shard! Vote for the Zero Tolerance Bill!

Post by A Black Death »

Almost forgot , WWJD?
A Black Death, fav songs by candle box rain and he calls home
if ya ever need help and your not a tool just pm me ill see what i can do for ya
14+years UO vet , reached vet status on ex in 3 months so got a q ill try to answer it too
User avatar
OldManAlewar
Legendary Scribe
Posts: 408
Joined: Sun Jan 06, 2008 3:42 pm

Re: Save the shard! Vote for the Zero Tolerance Bill!

Post by OldManAlewar »

A Black Death wrote:Almost forgot , WWJD?
now you're just trolling :P

Image
A Black Death
Elder Scribe
Posts: 108
Joined: Tue Feb 03, 2009 12:01 pm
Location: MO, usa
Contact:

Re: Save the shard! Vote for the Zero Tolerance Bill!

Post by A Black Death »

again @ old man LOLOLOLOLOL your my hero, do they make you in a small action figure i can put on my fridge or what
A Black Death, fav songs by candle box rain and he calls home
if ya ever need help and your not a tool just pm me ill see what i can do for ya
14+years UO vet , reached vet status on ex in 3 months so got a q ill try to answer it too
User avatar
OldManAlewar
Legendary Scribe
Posts: 408
Joined: Sun Jan 06, 2008 3:42 pm

Re: Save the shard! Vote for the Zero Tolerance Bill!

Post by OldManAlewar »

A Black Death wrote:again @ old man LOLOLOLOLOL your my hero, do they make you in a small action figure i can put on my fridge or what
ImageImage

Not yet, but they do make Big J

complete with "who's awesome? YOU'RE AWESOME" wink-and-point

...


oh by the way i'm posting again because someone broke Godwin's Law by calling Llexa a fascist.
"As a internet discussion grows longer, the probability of a comparison involving Nazis or Hitler approaches 1."
When said event occurs, you've automatically lost the Debate.

so: this topic is now about <dice roll> POLITE BLASPHEMY
Rune
Elder Scribe
Posts: 108
Joined: Wed Jan 14, 2009 6:11 pm

Re: Save the shard! Vote for the Zero Tolerance Bill!

Post by Rune »

well i do enjoy the /popcorn :nod: :dance
but i gotta say..oldman,bubba and black death
you 3 guys should be ashamed of yourself for lack of manners :verymad: ...trying to make anyone that disagree with you look funny :displeased:

honestly i thought you guys were better *looks disapointed*

ah almost forgot IBTL
<<< legendary slacker
A Black Death
Elder Scribe
Posts: 108
Joined: Tue Feb 03, 2009 12:01 pm
Location: MO, usa
Contact:

Re: Save the shard! Vote for the Zero Tolerance Bill!

Post by A Black Death »

OldManAlewar wrote:
A Black Death wrote:again @ old man LOLOLOLOLOL your my hero, do they make you in a small action figure i can put on my fridge or what
Not yet, but they do make Big J

complete with "who's awesome? YOU'RE AWESOME" wink-and-point

they say a pictures worth a 1000 words, well my man that would mean youve written what 10 thesis 3 biographys and a handful of essays on the forums here, and to me its all laughs duno how you find these side splitting gut busting photos day in and day out that fit the conversation so neatly almost as if it was pre-planned but impressive none the less keep up the good work ^^
A Black Death, fav songs by candle box rain and he calls home
if ya ever need help and your not a tool just pm me ill see what i can do for ya
14+years UO vet , reached vet status on ex in 3 months so got a q ill try to answer it too
A Black Death
Elder Scribe
Posts: 108
Joined: Tue Feb 03, 2009 12:01 pm
Location: MO, usa
Contact:

Re: Save the shard! Vote for the Zero Tolerance Bill!

Post by A Black Death »

Rune wrote:well i do enjoy the /popcorn :nod: :dance
but i gotta say..oldman,bubba and black death
you 3 guys should be ashamed of yourself for lack of manners :verymad: ...trying to make anyone that disagree with you look funny :displeased:

honestly i thought you guys were better *looks disapointed*

ah almost forgot IBTL

Sorry rune V hate to disapoint maby this will xplain
Image
A Black Death, fav songs by candle box rain and he calls home
if ya ever need help and your not a tool just pm me ill see what i can do for ya
14+years UO vet , reached vet status on ex in 3 months so got a q ill try to answer it too
User avatar
OldManAlewar
Legendary Scribe
Posts: 408
Joined: Sun Jan 06, 2008 3:42 pm

Re: Save the shard! Vote for the Zero Tolerance Bill!

Post by OldManAlewar »

Rune wrote:well i do enjoy the /popcorn :nod: :dance
but i gotta say..oldman,bubba and black death
you 3 guys should be ashamed of yourself for lack of manners :verymad: ...trying to make anyone that disagree with you look funny :displeased:

honestly i thought you guys were better *looks disapointed*

ah almost forgot IBTL
Sadly i wasnt 'trying to be funny', i pointed out faulty debate methods (slanted poll, strawman argument, etc) and made it perfectly clear my argument was with the argument and not the person.

Just because a persons opinion is stupid, doesnt mean the person is.

As for my outward signs of exasperation, thats a matter of taste on the side of people who are laughing.

that said: Godwins law has been triggered, this topic is now no longer about the original subject: we've lost

Image
User avatar
OldManAlewar
Legendary Scribe
Posts: 408
Joined: Sun Jan 06, 2008 3:42 pm

Re: Save the shard! Vote for the Zero Tolerance Bill!

Post by OldManAlewar »

A Black Death wrote:they say a pictures worth a 1000 words, well my man that would mean youve written what 10 thesis 3 biographys and a handful of essays on the forums here, and to me its all laughs duno how you find these side splitting gut busting photos day in and day out that fit the conversation so neatly almost as if it was pre-planned but impressive none the less keep up the good work ^^

i'll admit to keeping a funny pictures folder and knowing most silly internet memes by heart.

Image
User avatar
Harabakc
Legendary Scribe
Posts: 467
Joined: Thu Jun 22, 2006 2:43 pm

Re: Save the shard! Vote for the Zero Tolerance Bill!

Post by Harabakc »

The word fascist does not invoke goodwin's.
User avatar
OldManAlewar
Legendary Scribe
Posts: 408
Joined: Sun Jan 06, 2008 3:42 pm

Re: Save the shard! Vote for the Zero Tolerance Bill!

Post by OldManAlewar »

Harabakc wrote:The word fascist does not invoke goodwin's.
any comparison between your debate partner and nazi's/fascists/hitler will trigger Godwins and make you Lose The Game

and if you dont agree, you're a nazi fascist :P
Attachments
1230198284083.jpg
1230198284083.jpg (54.3 KiB) Viewed 5251 times
Llexa
Legendary Scribe
Posts: 294
Joined: Mon May 08, 2006 3:42 pm

Re: Save the shard! Vote for the Zero Tolerance Bill!

Post by Llexa »

all i can really say is wow, lots of childness in this thread; people who really dont read, or when they do, they only see what they wanna see. zero tolerance is a great structure, and again, majority here is not interested in actually reading, but instead pick out one sentence and drag it out for days, or one concept that you've decided in your head means something that it doesnt.
im not quoting people this time b/c there is way too much to quote.

black death:
your ridiculous "wwjd" statement is just that, pretty ridiculous. first of all you are making a very wrong correlation that i have written about in many other places. forgiveness (for mankind) does NOT excuse consequence. you can be completely forgiving of someone, but they still have created consequences for themselves due to their actions. forgiveness is a whole different freedom. we should forgive everyone, but doesn't mean we should get rid of consequences.

viollette:
how is it exactly that having consequences for actions is..."BS"...? never ONCE did i say that the ONLY punishment for EVERY wrong doing was to be banned. but again, a great example of not actually reading my posts for what they actually have in them, but seeing what you wanna see from them. and, if i have said it once ive said it 100 times, the poll was not meant to be a more-then-one-choice it was meant to be a petition. the 2nd option is very vague for that reason. i don't want a poll for those who "aren't interested" its a PETITION for those who are FOR it. so the 2nd answer is vague enough that people will just not use it and be on their way if they don't want to vote FOR it. you dont walk around with a petition with a spot for people who dont want to be involved in your cause. people who say no, you walk right past and on to the next. its a PRO ZERO TOLERANCE PETITION. there is really no other way for me to explain for a 101st time.

Beanah:
yes, we have some bad apples for sure, and we will always initially have them. the ENTIRE point of this thread was offering up zero tolerance as means to make life better for the decent players and the staff. less hours and hours they spend debating on the gray areas, less time the troublemakers have a soap box and less time players are actually effected by troublesome players. its win win situation. they need to know they can make quick and easy non biased consequences for people without having trouble makers waste their time with semantics keeping them out in the playing world longer to effect players who follow the rules. it's really that simple.

parrotletman:
wow, lol. uhm well for one we have standards here (atleast some) so no, people dont just have free reign to act however they want whenever they want all covered up by the ignore button. thats like, the laziest approach to the entire situation. and, anti-freedom? come on! consistency has NOTHING to do with anti-freedom and infact having a compass is liberating, unless you think it's not freedom if you aren't allowed to act however you want, lol. real life doesn't even offer that kind of corruption on that high of a level.
"We push and we push away,
For fear of facing our mistakes.
So we call it judgment,
And watch our friends, our world, ourselves... go comatose, inside."
User avatar
Bubba Ho Tep
Grandmaster Scribe
Posts: 88
Joined: Fri Jan 16, 2009 3:37 pm

Re: Save the shard! Vote for the Zero Tolerance Bill!

Post by Bubba Ho Tep »

OldManAlewar wrote: any comparison between your debate partner and nazi's/fascists/hitler will trigger Godwins and make you Lose The Game
Could you pm me those laws? Seem like something interesting to read...

And I gotta ask, are you sure you got the whole picture?
I said she was a fascist as much as we, who oppose the bill, are deliquents trying to protect our get outta jail free cards. It was an example to illustrate that she couldn't just divide the thread in people for the bill and people against Excelsior - which are two completely different things, and that seemed obvius for most people, but she still won't get it.

She then strongly denied being a fascist, from what she was not really accused - which confirmed one of two things: she didn't read anything at all; or she does believe that we're all criminal minds playing just for the opportunities to exploit or break the rules. Anyways, after that, I kinda made it into a joke.

But main point is: I've always stated that she's as much a fascist as you and I are deliquents who don't support the bill to keep our get outta jail free cards. And she understands that as me seriously calling her a fascist. What does that say about her opinion on the bill's opposers?

Edited: gotta ask though, what does Goodwin say about anyone who delliberately misses the point?

and Rune...
Rune wrote:but i gotta say..oldman,bubba and black death
you 3 guys should be ashamed of yourself for lack of manners :verymad: ...trying to make anyone that disagree with you look funny :displeased:

honestly i thought you guys were better *looks disapointed*
Read carefully my man... I did state that calling someone a fascist for not agreeing with me is as ridiculous as calling me a deliquent for not supporting the zero tolerance bill. I just didnt use the full words.
But hey, after not understanding the comparison, and reinforcing the idea that I do am a criminal master mind playing politics for my own good - me and everyone else who doesnt support the bill, well, I decided the ridiculous should be met with the ridiculous.
But let's not alter what was said: Llexa's as much a fascist as I am planning my getting away free after a lot of rule breaking. It's just a shame that she considers this paralel as me really calling her a fascist - and, it must be, my confession about my true intentions.
So yeah, all that's left to be said is "HAIL!"
Last edited by Bubba Ho Tep on Wed Apr 15, 2009 9:48 am, edited 1 time in total.
Locked