Banethorn wrote:Some of us don't have millions to spend on totems etc. The horselord is a fine first or second relayer when resist is not needed. My two horselord realyers put me over the edge so I could handle higher end content. Thus make more money and get better gear. It is all a progression. I am sure some of you 10 year people started with lower lvl items and worked your way up?
You don't need millions. The horselord is trash and worth nothing, as is a basic 3x14, but it at least has SOME stats, and is also worth nothing. To be honest you could relayer an NPC bought longsword and it would still increase your power level. That doesn't make it a good idea or good value for money.
I had some "skeptical" relayers when I was young but I at least used items that had some stats, ANY stats, for those. I had a cavorting club relayer at one point. It at least has some resists and stuff. Many points worth of stats, horselord has +5 dex and 1 mana regen, essentially 26 points.
If you stuffed up and relayered a horselord once, that's OK, learn from it and move on. If you relayered a horselord as your second relayer... well ....
Wil wrote:It's not so bad as a relayer. You get 20 "free" points in the 5 bonus dex it comes with and it has enough luck to skip one of the four 100ED luck deeds you'd otherwise need to put 400 luck on it.
I agree with heaps of what you say Wil and I always find your posts insightful, but I think you're categorically wrong here. It is the definition of a bad relayer, not "not so bad".
A 3x14 resist, as stated, also worthless like the horselord comes with 210 "free" points from the resists. That's over 10x more points than the horselord, not counting the luck. And if you're adding luck with spend points to your relayer then... well... I can't help you there. You may as well just leave your ED in piles on the ground to decay.
Furthermore, if you're putting 400 luck onto a horselord relayer you're doing it wrong. I'm sorry, I am not trying to be rude, but it's truth. That's literally the definition of throwing good money after bad.
There are 1001 different items that are basically free with better stats than the horselord and are easily many times more effective as a relayer. [pm John Warren in game and I will give you a bag full of 3x14 resist weapons, choose an easy one to level and use that. I mean give, as in free. Please. Please don't waste ED relayering a horselord, you will regret it.
Handrius wrote:Ive also sold a relayered shirt horselord for 400eds. so worthless is all based at whos looking at it.
Paying 100ed less for a relayer is a reasonable deal, but you can clearly see it's also an indictment of how bad the weapon is, right? If it was actually good you wouldn't have sold it. If it was actually good it would have held more value.
I guess the point I am trying to make is to help a newer player make a better decision. You may think I'm being snobby and looking down on players with less gear or worse relayers than me or something along those lines... but I am actually trying to be helpful to this new player, unlike the people trying to convince him to make the same mistakes they did.... Within 12 months, guaranteed, they will regret relayering a horselord. Probably more like 6 months. They'll be wishing they could have their 500ED back to relayer something with stats. 3x14 resist weapons don't even sell anymore, they are free, if anyone is charging for a plain 3x14 they are ripping you off, [pm John Warren and I can give you a bunch, I don't even bother looting them any more. 4x14 resists are rarer but also rather cheap. These are significantly better than the horselord, they don't cost you anything.
In the end, it's a game, do what you want, but 500ed is 500ed. I cannot recommend strongly enough that you do not relayer this weapon.